Red Flags and Contraindications: When NOT to Use Certain Enrichment Activities

Part. 3
‍
Enrichment is an essential component of canine well-being, but not all activities are appropriate for every dog. For the educated practitioner, recognising red flags and adapting plans is critical - not only to prevent injury but also to ensure that enrichment complements, rather than conflicts with, osteopathic care.

Why Contraindications Matter

Enrichment introduces variability in movement and environment, which is generally beneficial for tissue health and neural stimulation. However, in dogs with underlying musculoskeletal dysfunction, systemic illness, or pain-related behaviour, some activities can exacerbate problems. Overlooking these considerations risks compromising both physical integrity and recovery.

Key Red Flags Before Recommending Enrichment

1. Acute Lameness or Sudden Postural Changes
   If a dog presents with new or worsening lameness, reluctance to bear weight, or asymmetrical posture, enrichment involving dynamic movement, such as balance work or tug games, should be avoided until a full assessment is performed. These signs may indicate joint pathology, muscle tear, or neurological involvement that requires veterinary evaluation.
   
   
2. Signs of Pain During Activity
   Yawning, lip licking, tail tucking, or freezing mid-activity are subtle yet significant indicators of discomfort. Persisting despite these behaviours can lead to tissue overload, increased fascial tension, and compensatory strain. Activities should be paused and adapted to reduce intensity or eliminated altogether.
   
   
3. Neurological Concerns
   Dogs showing ataxia, knuckling, or delayed proprioceptive responses should not engage in unstable surface work or agility-based enrichment. These activities require precise neuromuscular control and can increase the risk of falls or further neurological compromise.
   
   
4. Excessive Fatigue or Stress
   Cognitive enrichment is beneficial, but prolonged problem-solving tasks can heighten stress in anxious dogs. Similarly, physically demanding enrichment in unfit or geriatric dogs can lead to muscular fatigue and joint overload. Monitoring duration and intensity is essential.
   

Activity-Specific Contraindications

• Proprioceptive Equipment: Avoid in dogs with acute spinal issues, significant joint laxity (e.g., severe hip dysplasia), or post-surgical instability.
  
  
• Tug Games: Contraindicated in dogs with cervical pain, temporomandibular dysfunction, or recent dental work.
  
  
• Fetch or Jumping Activities: Should not be recommended for dogs with forelimb lameness, elbow dysplasia, or advanced osteoarthritis due to repetitive concussive loading.
  
  
• Puzzle Toys: While generally safe, they may cause frustration in dogs with cognitive decline or those exhibiting compulsive behaviours - requiring careful observation.
  

Integrating Clinical Reasoning with Osteopathic Principles

The osteopathic approach emphasises the body’s ability to self-regulate and adapt - but only when conditions allow. Introducing enrichment during acute inflammatory stages or when pain inhibits normal motion can disrupt this process. Instead, enrichment should be phased in gradually, following tissue recovery and restoration of baseline mobility.

When to Refer Before Proceeding

Persistent pain, progressive neurological signs, systemic lethargy, or unexplained behavioural shifts warrant veterinary referral before implementing enrichment. Collaboration with the primary care veterinarian ensures that underlying pathology is addressed prior to introducing activities designed to enhance functional adaptability.

Final Thoughts

Enrichment is powerful, but not universally benign. Its effectiveness depends on timing, individualisation, and clinical judgment. By applying osteopathic principles alongside evidence-informed caution, practitioners can ensure that enrichment serves as a tool for healing and resilience rather than an unintended source of harm.

‍